Monday, September 30, 2024

Manchester United vs Tottenham Match Review

 

Bruno Fernandes retreating to dressing room after recieving red card against Tottenham

My first take on the game on Sunday was that United were going to win no matter what, but the way they started the game was shocking and appalling. Sitting down and watching the game I could feel my skin crawling with disgust at such a performance, however I still believe that we could have performed better in the second half, but the red card to our best player basically canceled out any chance we had of a comeback.

Who Is To Blame Erik Or The Players

Hearing that Manchester United manager Erik Ten Hag is facing the sack is definitely not new to any football fan out there, well it's another poor performance and the self-proclaimed social media jury is out on Ten Hag. United's last loss was against Liverpool who beat them three-nil at Old Trafford after that was a three nill dominant win over Southampton, a 7 nil thumping of Barnsley, and a game away at Crystal Palace which any reasonable individual will agree should have ended in the first half. The only game where United lifted their foot from the gas was the 1 all draw against FC Twente in the Europa League, during all of these games there was a lot of praise aimed at United for keeping possession, carrying out repeated patterns of play, creating a lot of chances and playing out from the back, but facing another big team in the Premier League, the United players forgot all of that discipline and were so bad they could not keep the ball for 5 seconds in the first half. Not surprisingly all fingers were pointed at the manager, "he should be sacked", United has no playing style" as if it was not the same United team we were all praising last week. I believe United's problem has strongly to do with mentality and consistency, against both Liverpool and Tottenham United seemed to play well after they had already lost both games, they played better than Liverpool in the second half and played better than Tottenham in the second despite being a man down and conceding two goals. I think Ten Hag needs to work on his players mentality and confidence, especially in such high-pressure games, because United can definitely not be this bad.

Bruno Fernandes Red Card

From a United point of view, we were as bad as we could possibly be in that first half, but I have seen United be this bad and still come out to play better in the second half, the game was against Tottenham not Liverpool or City, I was convinced we were going to stage a comeback in the second half. But that belief was snuffed out when Chris Kavanagh showed a red card to our skipper, I'm not going to talk about my own opinion for the sake of being just, but rather I would point out to two retired referees who gave out their opinion. Former football referee Cheif Kieth Hackett had this to say "This was a very unfortunate slip by Bruno Fernandes on a disastrous afternoon for Manchester United. I can see why the referee may have decided this was worthy of a red card, as Fernandes looked to challenge James Maddison with Tottenham on the breakaway. However, after multiple viewings, I lean towards a yellow card. I feel the referee Chris Kavanagh would have benefitted from being asked to look at the incident again on the pitch-side monitor. He was in an excellent position and the VAR would go with the referee's call- there was no way they would overturn this as they would say it is not a clear and obvious error- but giving him the benefit of multiple replays and angles could have resulted in a different decision." 

And these are the words of former referee and Sky Sports analyst Dermot Gallagher "Right, a lot of debate. Look, that's the referee's view, I don't think he can see it, that's my first point. I don't think the referee sees the challenge happen. The assistant flags it, he has a different view and angle. When you play it through, you can see it's a glancing blow, he doesn't catch him as he thinks. I can understand the referee not seeing it, he has to go off the assistant's view on that, he thinks it's high and caught him, but he hasn't. It's an optical illusion when you see it, a more palatable decision would've been a yellow card".

What Is Next For Man United 

The decision from the Man United dressing room after Sunday's game was to "reset" and go again at FC Porto on Thursday, I believe the players are still firmly behind Erik Ten Hag, and I expect to see more effort and motivation from them going forward, but I have seen this team bounce back from more horrible situations than this, so I strongly believe they would do so again.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment